Armenia’s Ministry of Justice has proposed minimum monetary compensation of one million drams for insult and two million drams for defamation. What problem is the government trying to solve, and could the proposal become a means of putting financial pressure on the independent press? Ashot Melikyan, chairman of the Committee to Protect Freedom of Expression, shared his view.
According to Melikyan, the proposal to set minimum compensation in insult and defamation cases is an unwarranted intervention in established judicial practice and does not meet European standards. He argues that the existing maximum compensation amounts — three million and six million drams respectively — are already high relative to Armenia’s social and economic conditions. The Committee warned when the law was adopted that such sums would place an additional financial burden on newsrooms.
Courts should be able to determine compensation
Melikyan stressed that the Committee does not defend people who insult others or make defamatory statements. The problem, he said, is also that many officials and politicians perceive objective criticism as insult or defamation and sue news outlets to settle scores. “When we do not have an established independent judiciary, and judges in many cases issue decisions with a political dimension, those figures manage to settle scores,” he said.
According to the Committee chairman, a positive trend had recently emerged in judicial practice. Courts generally did not grant claimants’ requests for the maximum compensation of three or six million drams. Instead, they awarded amounts that were tens of times smaller.
He emphasized that every case must be assessed individually, because information that is untrue is not automatically defamatory. A court should examine the specific circumstances and determine what amount of compensation is justified. “With this bill, the authorities are, in effect, restricting a person’s ability to go to court. If someone seeks compensation, they must ask for at least one million drams for insult or two million for defamation, no less,” Melikyan said.
In his assessment, this approach deprives courts of the ability to set monetary compensation in line with the circumstances of a case. If the proposed rules are adopted and a court decides to award monetary compensation, it would have to set an amount between one and three million drams for insult, or between two and six million for defamation. It could not award less than those minimum amounts.
Committee proposes seeking a European expert opinion
Melikyan said the Committee to Protect Freedom of Expression has monitored lawsuits against journalists and news outlets for decades. Its research shows that when courts awarded compensation of 200,000–300,000 drams or less, claimants generally did not appeal that part of the judgment.
He said this demonstrated that existing judicial practice had allowed compensation to be set according to the circumstances of each case, without a need for state intervention. “However much they try to present this bill positively in its explanatory note, I maintain that it does not meet European standards,” Melikyan said.
He proposed sending the bill to European bodies for an expert opinion. Melikyan also objected to the fact that the Committee had not been consulted at all while the proposal was drafted. In his view, recent changes to Article 1087.1 of the Civil Code — from the increase in maximum compensation amounts to the current initiative — have been driven largely by emotional factors.
Melikyan called for the proposal to be withdrawn and for open discussions involving the journalism community. Such discussions, he said, should clarify what risks the bill’s authors see and how they justify the proposed changes.

